NDIR, TDLAS or photoacoustic spectroscopy?
There is no single best technology for every measurement. The right choice depends on the gas, range, matrix, dynamics and number of compounds.
All three methods use the interaction of radiation with gas, but generate the measurement signal differently. This affects selectivity, configuration flexibility and application requirements.
NDIR — practical infrared absorption measurement
NDIR measures attenuation of infrared radiation in selected absorption bands. It is widely used for continuous CO₂, CO, CH₄ and other infrared-active gases.
Mature design and multiple channels are advantages. Overlapping bands, humidity and matrix composition must still be evaluated. Selectivity depends on optics, filters, cell length and compensation algorithms.
TDLAS — a narrow line and high selectivity
TDLAS scans a laser across a selected absorption line of a specific gas, enabling fast and selective measurement in a well-defined application.
It is usually configured for a particular compound and range. Laser availability, optical path length, pressure and temperature affect the design. TDLAS is not automatically multigas or optimal for every concentration level.
PAS and CEPAS — absorption converted into pressure
In photoacoustic spectroscopy, modulated radiation absorbed by the gas causes periodic heating and pressure variation. The detector measures the resulting photoacoustic signal.
Cantilever-microphone systems can provide high sensitivity with small sample volumes. Multigas configurations use suitable sources and bands but still require interference and matrix evaluation.
How to choose
Start with gas, range and sample conditions. Compare detection limit, selectivity, response, number of compounds, stability and sample-path requirements. A technology label alone does not determine system quality.
| Criterion | NDIR | TDLAS | PAS/CEPAS |
|---|---|---|---|
| Measurement character | Absorption in selected bands | Laser at a selected line | Photoacoustic signal after absorption |
| Multigas capability | Possible through several channels | Usually focused on a selected gas | Possible with a suitable configuration |
| Strength | Maturity and process flexibility | Selectivity and fast response | High sensitivity and small sample volume |
| Verify | Interferences and humidity | Range, line and optical conditions | Interferences, source configuration and matrix |
Example: CH₄ in two different tasks
Process biogas may contain tens of volume percent CH₄ together with CO₂, H₂S and water vapour. A multigas NDIR configuration with additional sensors can be practical here. High-quality biomethane control may instead focus on highly precise and fast methane measurement in a narrow composition range, where a specialised TDLAS can offer an advantage.
Trace CH₄ and N₂O emission studies prioritise low detection limits and multigas measurement from a small sample, which can favour photoacoustics. The same gas symbol therefore does not imply the same measurement configuration.
Information to prepare
- Target gas and potential interferences
- Lowest and highest expected concentration
- Required process response time
- Single-compound or multigas measurement
- Sample temperature, pressure and humidity
- Sampling, conditioning and reference-gas availability
Frequently asked questions
Is TDLAS always more accurate than NDIR?
No. Performance depends on gas, range, matrix and analyser design. TDLAS can be highly selective, while NDIR may be the better and simpler multicomponent option.
Can PAS measure several gases?
Yes, with suitable sources or filters and compensation. Available gases and interferences must be confirmed for the configuration.
Which method is best for biogas?
NDIR is common for routine CH₄ and CO₂; TDLAS can support selected biomethane-quality tasks. The final choice depends on range and objective.
Manufacturer source materials
Related solutions
Open related solution and instrument pages.
Discuss your measurement with MES-EKO
Send the gas, range, sample conditions and operating mode. We will select the method, analyser and measurement path.
Send an enquiry